November 7, 2011
The Un-Open Yet Flexible Marriage
I just finished reading Sex at Dawn which makes the case that we humans are at our core not monogamous creatures. That in many ways – monogamy is a societal concept – imposed on us by religion and many other factors. I loved the book, but for me personally it’s a big leap from there to being poly amorous or in an open marriage. And yet my memoir, Shameless: How I Ditched The Diet, Got Naked, Found True Pleasure and Somehow Got Home in Time to Cook Dinner is all about wanting more….and staying married.
So, how do you get more – and stay monogamous? Is there a solution outside of going from marriage to marriage in a serial monogamy routine that so many of us fall into because we need more on some level? Is there something in-between monogamy and full out polyamory or open marriage? Right now – this is a “Hot Topic” on Psychology Today.
Is polyamory the new more accepted term for Open Marriage? We are certainly hearing that term more and more and some are saying that it is next big sexual revolution. I am living something else – which I call the Monogamish Marriage. Which is a kind of middle ground of sorts.
When I first thought of the term “expanded monogamy” I thought that I had coined a new term. But a quick search on google turned up several references to expanded monogamy with different definitions. In my version of expanded monogamy – a couple sets the rules of sexual exploration that fit with their own set of personal boundaries that in my own rule book does not include taking a traditional lover. In my take on expanded monogamy – I am not talking about what been called an “Open Marriage”. My version has boundaries that may seem outside of the box for some – but for others may seem quite restrictive.
What is agreeable to one couple may not be agreeable to another. In my story - Shameless – I realize that I created a form of expanded monogamy and developed with my husband a way for me to explore my sexuality that did not fit the traditional outline of monogamy but was not polygamy either. I explored the concept of polyamory by reading a wonderful book on the subject by Deborah Anapol – but the concept was quite right for me. I need something else – new language! And if I have learned anything in my years as a fertility advocate and sex educator – if we don’t have language for something – we get very confused.
We are also not so good at finding middle places in our society. Many people on my book tour keep asking me questions like “How did your husband feel about you going to a Tantra workshop?” or “”Did you husband get jealous of you working with hands on sexual healers?”
No matter where I am in the country – I am asked the same questions over and over again about my adventures into the underground world of sacred sexuality. In my search for language – I am embracing the term expanded monogamy, and I would like to introduce it to you if you are unfamiliar with it.
In my own expanded monogamous marriage – I have room to go to sexuality workshops that include me exploring my own sexuality with myself and with others within boundaries and usually in a supervised workshop setting. I am able to be playful in my sexuality – which keeps my own inner fire alive and my marriage sexually interesting. It has become essential to me to be able to explore who I am as an individual as well as in my marriage.
In my own expanded monogamous marriage – both my husband and I have the space to work with sexological body workers and sacred intimates who are there to support us on our own individual paths. We attend tantra workshops – which may include us working with sexual energy techniques like moving our breath with other people – or eye gazing.
Having the space to explore and experiment with my sexuality within the boundaries of an expanded monogamy has supported my 30 year marriage into a place where both my husband and I are happy and has helped us keep the light burning in our own marriage bed. Having room to expand your sexuality and explore over time may turn a once sexless marriage into something else. Creating some room in our relationships for turning up the heat on our sexuality does not have to mean leaving the marriage or having an affair. We simply have to bring this possibility out into the world.
If we have the room to experiment and expand our own sexuality without shame – I believe that more people would stay within their relationships. We just need a little more room to breathe. It’s about creating sexual agreements that work for each partnership – and allowing each other the room to grow without ditching your lives.







sending...


Thank you for your article, Pam! I would love to hear more people speak about engaging in “Threesomes” as a way to express expanded monogamy. This is something that my boyfriend has suggested. I can agree with it “on paper”, but it is certainly much harder to put into practice. I would love to find a place to speak with others who have found this a “successful” solution to moving beyond monogamy.
Polyamory is an open marriage style. There are different styles of open marriages which I think are different than swinging or having an extramarital relationship just because an individual is bored.
Those who are in open marriages who seek relationships that focus on love and emotional involvement rather than just straight sex I think have a poly style of what we see as an open marriage instead of just sex and what experts refer to as “recreational friendships” (Is that like smoking pot for recreational purposes? That always cracked me up.) I think when we have extramarital relationships that are purely recreational that would have a swinging flavor or style to it, yes?
Then there are other factors that psychologists have added to this with big words like “sociosexuality” and everything that entails.
What I have found in my own studies if this fascinating subject is that regardless of what category you find yourself in there are common denominators — it’s not really socially accepted, there are jealousy issues even in the most stable and best relationships, and the couple wants to remain a couple not be single. Make sense?
What’s even more remarkable is that the research shows that some folks who are poly are swingers while others are not. That makes sense to me.
One of my dear friends tells me that people with open marriages want their cake and eat it too. My philosophy is why can’t you begin with dessert first? Why do we always have to have the appetizer and salad first? And really what is the main meal when it comes to sex?
I apologize for the length of this comment but this topic is fascinating to me because of all of the layers involved.
Great post.
Just had a fabulous conversation about this post, Pam, that could be summed up with this sentence of yours: “We are also not so good at finding middle places in our society.”
We’re all so sold on duality — right and wrong, black and white, good and bad, married or single — that living where we *really* are (always in the gray) is tough, tough, tough. Even just trying to explain those murky notions is (aggravatingly) challenging at times. We find comfort in those dualities. But that reminds me of the old 12-step phrases about comfort being a warm, even if smelly, hole in the ground.
Fabulous comment Tracy! Thank you for taking the time to write and expand the conversation. You are right on!
Hugs,
Pamela